There are articles floating around on the company NDB about to produce battery-sized nuclear generators. As with any “revolutionary breakthrough” you might want to take a closer look. I did a rough calculation what kind of output a power source based on C-14 decay can produce.

The result isn't exactly surprising: sure, this kind of “battery” has an enormous energy density but you need thousands of years to actually harvest the energy. Even assuming that no energy is converted to heat (rather unlikely), the output of a 1 kg battery will be below 3 watt.

Show thread

That should be barely enough to power a smartphone. So the use cases mentioned in the articles are complete bullshit: even an electric bike would need at least 100 kg in battery. Electric cars? Just forget it…

Show thread

This approach is only something for low-power scenarios where you cannot change the battery. And in fact, similar power sources have been used for space probes.

Never mind that the cost calculation is also bogus: nuclear waste will only be free as long as it is useless.

Show thread

Ouch, typo in the image – 1.81 * 10^19, not 1.81 * 10^20. Also, it's 2.9 J/s, not 29. The end result is correct, I forgot to correct a mistake for intermediate steps. ☹️

· · Web · 0 · 0 · 0
Sign in to participate in the conversation
Infosec Exchange

A Mastodon instance for info/cyber security-minded people.